A large collection of NLP model explanations and accompanying analysis tools

thermostat

Thermostat is a large collection of NLP model explanations and accompanying analysis tools.

• Combines explainability methods from the captum library with Hugging Face's datasets and transformers.
• Mitigates repetitive execution of common experiments in Explainable NLP and thus reduces the environmental impact and financial roadblocks.
• Increases comparability and replicability of research.
• Reduces the implementational burden.

This work is described in our paper accepted to EMNLP 2021 System Demonstrations :
Nils Feldhus, Robert Schwarzenberg, and Sebastian Möller.
Thermostat: A Large Collection of NLP Model Explanations and Analysis Tools. 2021.

arXiv pre-print available here: https://arxiv.org/abs/2108.13961

Installation

With pip

pip install thermostat-datasets

Usage

Downloading a dataset requires just two lines of code:

import thermostatdata = thermostat.load("imdb-bert-lig")

Thermostat datasets can be addressed and loaded with an identifier string that contains three basic coordinates: Dataset, Model, and Explainer. In this example, the dataset is IMDb (sentiment analysis of movie reviews), the model is a BERT model fine-tuned on the IMDb data, the explanations are generated using a (Layer) Integrated Gradients explainer.

data then contains the following columns/features:

• attributions (the attributions for each token for each data point; type: List of floats)
• idx (the index of the instance in the dataset)
• input_ids (the token IDs of the original dataset; type: List of ints)
• label (the label of the original dataset; type: int)
• predictions (the class logits of the classifier/downstream model; type: List of floats)

This is the raw content stored in each of the instances of data:

If we print data, we get more info such as the actual names of the dataset, the explainer and the model:

print(data) > IMDb dataset, BERT model, Layer Integrated Gradients explanations> Explainer: LayerIntegratedGradients> Model: textattack/bert-base-uncased-imdb> Dataset: imdb

Indexing an instance

We can simply index the loaded dataset like a list:

import thermostatinstance = thermostat.load("imdb-bert-lig")[429]

Visualizing attributions as a heatmap

We can apply .render() to every instance to display a heatmap visualization generated by the displaCy library.

instance.render()  # instance refers to the variable assigned in the last codebox

Get simple tuple-based heatmap

The explanation attribute stores a tuple-based heatmap with the token, the attribution, and the token index as elements.

print(instance.explanation)  # instance refers to the variable assigned in the second to last codebox > [('[CLS]', 0.0, 0), ('amazing', 2.3141794204711914, 1), ('movie', 0.06655970215797424, 2), ('.', -0.47832658886909485, 3), ('some', 0.15708176791667938, 4), ('of', -0.02931656688451767, 5), ('the', -0.08834744244813919, 6), ('script', -0.2660972774028778, 7), ('writing', -0.4021594822406769, 8), ('could', -0.19280624389648438, 9), ('have', -0.015477157197892666, 10), ('been', -0.21898044645786285, 11), ('better', -0.4095713794231415, 12), ...]  # abbreviated

The heatmap attribute displays it as a pandas table:

print(instance.heatmap) > token_index    0         1          2         3          4         5    \ token        [CLS]         i       went       and        saw      this attribution      0 -0.117371  0.0849944  0.165192  0.0362542 -0.029687 text_field    text      text       text      text       text      text token_index       6         7         8          9          10         11   \ token           movie      last     night      after      being     coaxed attribution  0.533126  0.240222  0.171116 -0.0450005 -0.0103401  0.0166524 text_field       text      text      text       text       text       text token_index        13         14          15         16         17   \ token               to         by           a        few    friends attribution  0.0269605 -0.0213463  0.00761083  0.0216749  0.0579834 text_field        text       text        text       text       text # abbreviated

Modifying the load function

thermostat.load() is a wrapper around datasets.load_dataset() and you can use any keyword arguments from load_dataset() in load(), too (except path, name and split which are reserved), e.g. if you want to use another cache directory, you can use the cache_dir argument in thermostat.load().

Explainers

Datasets + Models

= Dataset is downloadable

= Dataset is finished, but not uploaded yet

= Currently running on cluster (x n = number of jobs/screens)

= Issue

IMDb

imdb is a sentiment analysis dataset with 2 classes (pos and neg). The available split is the test subset containing 25k examples.
Example configuration: imdb-xlnet-lig

Name		lgxa	lig	lime	occ	svs
ALBERT (albert)	textattack/albert-base-v2-imdb
BERT (bert)	textattack/bert-base-uncased-imdb
ELECTRA (electra)	monologg/electra-small-finetuned-imdb
RoBERTa (roberta)	textattack/roberta-base-imdb
XLNet (xlnet)	textattack/xlnet-base-cased-imdb

MultiNLI

multi_nli is a textual entailment dataset. The available split is the validation_matched subset containing 9815 examples.
Example configuration: multi_nli-roberta-lime

Name		lgxa	lig	lime	occ	svs
ALBERT (albert)	prajjwal1/albert-base-v2-mnli
BERT (bert)	textattack/bert-base-uncased-MNLI
ELECTRA (electra)	howey/electra-base-mnli
RoBERTa (roberta)	textattack/roberta-base-MNLI
XLNet (xlnet)	textattack/xlnet-base-cased-MNLI

XNLI

xnli is a textual entailment dataset. It provides the test set of MultiNLI through the "en" configuration. The fine-tuned models used here are the same as the MultiNLI ones. The available split is the test subset containing 5010 examples.
Example configuration: xnli-roberta-lime

Name		lgxa	lig	lime	occ	svs
ALBERT (albert)	prajjwal1/albert-base-v2-mnli
BERT (bert)	textattack/bert-base-uncased-MNLI
ELECTRA (electra)	howey/electra-base-mnli
RoBERTa (roberta)	textattack/roberta-base-MNLI
XLNet (xlnet)	textattack/xlnet-base-cased-MNLI

AG News

ag_news is a news topic classification dataset. The available split is the test subset containing 7600 examples.
Example configuration: ag_news-albert-svs

Name		lgxa	lig	lime	occ	svs
ALBERT (albert)	textattack/albert-base-v2-ag-news
BERT (bert)	textattack/bert-base-uncased-ag-news
RoBERTa (roberta)	textattack/roberta-base-ag-news

Contribute a dataset

New explanation datasets must follow the JSONL format and include the five fields attributions, idx, input_ids, label and predictions as described above in "Usage".

Please follow the instructions for writing a dataset loading script in the official docs of datasets.

Provide the additional Thermostat metadata via the list of builder configs (click here to see the Thermostat implementation of builder configs).

Necessary fields include...

• name : The unique identifier string, e.g. including the three coordinates <DATASET>-<MODEL>-<EXPLAINER>
• dataset : The full name of the dataset, usually follows the naming convention in datasets, e.g. "imdb"
• explainer : The full name of the explainer, usually follows the naming convention in captum, e.g. "LayerIntegratedGradients"
• model : The full name of the model, usually follows the naming convention in transformers, e.g. "textattack/bert-base-uncased-imdb"
• label_column : The name of the column in the JSONL file that contains the label, usually "label"
• label_classes : The list of label names or classes, e.g. ["entailment", "neutral", "contradiction"] for NLI datasets
• text_column : Either a string (if there is only one text column) or a list of strings that identify the column in the JSONL file that contains the text(s), e.g. "text" (IMDb) or ["premise", "hypothesis"] (NLI)
• description : Should at least state the full names of the three coordinates, can optionally include more info such as hyperparameter choices
• data_url : The URL to the data storage, e.g. a Google Drive link

plus features which you can copy from the codebox below:

features={"attributions": "attributions", "predictions": "predictions", "input_ids": "input_ids"}

While debugging, you can wrap your data with the Thermopack class and see if it correctly parses your data:

import thermostatfrom datasets import load_datasetdata = load_dataset('your_dataset') thermostat.Thermopack(data)

If you're successful, follow the official instructions for sharing a community provided dataset at the HuggingFace hub.

At first, all Thermostat contributions will have to be loaded via the code example above. Please notify us of existing explanation datasets by creating an Issue with the tag Contribution and a maintainer of this repository will add your dataset to the Thermostat configs s.t. it can be accessed by everyone via thermostat.load().

Cite Thermostat

@inproceedings{feldhus2021thermostat,
    title={Thermostat: A Large Collection of NLP Model Explanations and Analysis Tools},
    author={Nils Feldhus and Robert Schwarzenberg and Sebastian Möller},
    year={2021},
    editor = {Heike Adel and Shuming Shi},
    booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2021 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing: System Demonstrations},
}

Disclaimer

We give no warranties for the correctness of the heatmaps or any other part of the data. This is evolving work and will be hot-patched continuously.

The Thermostat project follows the ACL and ACM Code of Ethics.

Acknowledgements

The majority of the codebase, especially regarding the combination of transformers and captum, stems from our other recent project Empirical Explainers.

GitHub

GitHub - DFKI-NLP/thermostat: Collection of NLP model explanations and accompanying analysis tools

Collection of NLP model explanations and accompanying analysis tools - GitHub - DFKI-NLP/thermostat: Collection of NLP model explanations and accompanying analysis tools

GitHubDFKI-NLP