Unmarkd

Unmarkd is a BeautifulSoup-powered Markdown reverser written in Python and for Python.

Why

This is created as a StackSearch (one of my other projects) dependancy. In order to create a better API, I needed a way to reverse HTML. So I created this.

There are similar projects (written in Ruby) but I have not found any written in Python (or for Python) later I found a popular library, html2text. But Unmarkd still is still better. See comparison.

Installation

You know the drill

pip install unmarkd

Known issues

  • Nested lists are not properly indented (#4) Fixed in #11
  • Blockquote bug (#18)

Comparison

TL;DR: Html2Text is fast. If you don't need much configuration, you could use Html2Text for the little speed increase.

Speed

TL;DR: Unmarkd < Html2Text

Html2Text is basically faster:

benchmark

(The DOC variable used can be found here)

Unmarkd sacrifices speed for power

Html2Text directly uses Python's html.parser module (in the standard library). On the other hand, Unmarkd uses the powerful HTML parsing library, beautifulsoup4. BeautifulSoup can be configured to use different HTML parsers. In Unmarkd, we configure it to use Python's html.parser, too.

But another layer of code means more code is ran.

I hope that's a good explanation of the speed difference.

Correctness

TL;DR: Unmarkd == Html2Text

I actually found two html-to-markdown libraries. One of them was Tomd which had an incorrect implementation:

tomd_cant_handle

It seems to be abandoned, anyway.

Now with Html2Text and Unmarkd:

correct

In other words, they work

Configurability

TL;DR: Unmarkd > Html2Text

This is Unmarkd's strong point.

In Html2Text, you only have a limited set of options.

In Unmarkd, you can subclass the BaseUnmarker and implement conversions for new tags (e.g. <q>), etc. In my opinion, it's much easier to extend and configure Unmarkd.

Unmarkd was originally written as a StackSearch dependancy.

Html2Text has no options for configuring parsing of code blocks. Unmarkd does

Documentation

Here's an example of basic usage

import unmarkd
print(unmarkd.unmark("<b>I <i>love</i> markdown!</b>"))
# Output: **I *love* markdown!**

or something more complex (shamelessly taken from here):

import unmarkd
html_doc = R"""<h1 id="sample-markdown">Sample Markdown</h1>
<p>This is some basic, sample markdown.</p>
<h2 id="second-heading">Second Heading</h2>
<ul>
<li>Unordered lists, and:<ol>
<li>One</li>
<li>Two</li>
<li>Three</li>
</ol>
</li>
<li>More</li>
</ul>
<blockquote>
<p>Blockquote</p>
</blockquote>
<p>And <strong>bold</strong>, <em>italics</em>, and even <em>italics and later <strong>bold</strong></em>. Even <del>strikethrough</del>. <a href="https://markdowntohtml.com">A link</a> to somewhere.</p>
<p>And code highlighting:</p>
<pre><code class="lang-js"><span class="hljs-keyword">var</span> foo = <span class="hljs-string">'bar'</span>;

<span class="hljs-function"><span class="hljs-keyword">function</span> <span class="hljs-title">baz</span><span class="hljs-params">(s)</span> </span>{
   <span class="hljs-keyword">return</span> foo + <span class="hljs-string">':'</span> + s;
}
</code></pre>
<p>Or inline code like <code>var foo = &#39;bar&#39;;</code>.</p>
<p>Or an image of bears</p>
<p><img src="http://placebear.com/200/200" alt="bears"></p>
<p>The end ...</p>
"""
print(unmarkd.unmark(html_doc))

and the output:

    # Sample Markdown


    This is some basic, sample markdown.

    ## Second Heading



    - Unordered lists, and:
     1. One
     2. Two
     3. Three
    - More

    >Blockquote


    And **bold**, *italics*, and even *italics and later **bold***. Even ~~strikethrough~~. [A link](https://markdowntohtml.com) to somewhere.

    And code highlighting:


    ```js
    var foo = 'bar';

    function baz(s) {
       return foo + ':' + s;
    }
    ```


    Or inline code like `var foo = 'bar';`.

    Or an image of bears

    ![bears](http://placebear.com/200/200)

    The end ...

Extending

Brief Overview

Most functionality should be covered by the BasicUnmarker class defined in unmarkd.unmarkers.

If you need to reverse markdown from StackExchange (as in the case for my other project), you may use the StackOverflowUnmarker (or it's alias, StackExchangeUnmarker), which is also defined in unmarkd.unmarkers.

Customizing

If the above two classes do not suit your needs, you can subclass the unmarkd.unmarkers.BaseUnmarker abstract class.

Currently, you can optionally override the following methods:

  • detect_language (parameters: 1)
    • Parameters:
      • html: bs4.BeautifulSoup
    • When a fenced code block is approached, this function is called with a parameter of type bs4.BeautifulSoup passed to it; this is the element the code block was detected from (i.e. pre).
    • This function is responsible for detecting the programming language (or returning '' if none was detected) of the code block.
    • Note: This method is different from unmarkd.unmarkers.BasicUnmarker. It is simpler and does less checking/filtering

But Unmarkd is more flexible than that.

Customizable constants

There are currently 3 constants you may override:

  • Formats:
    NOTE: Use the Format String Syntax
    • UNORDERED_FORMAT
      • The string format of unordered (bulleted) lists.
    • ORDERED_FORMAT
      • The string format of ordered (numbered) lists.
  • Miscellaneous:
    • ESCAPABLES
      • A container (preferably a set) of length-1 str that should be escaped
Customize converting HTML tags

For an HTML tag some_tag, you can customize how it's converted to markdown by overriding a method like so:

from unmarkd.unmarkers import BaseUnmarker
class MyCustomUnmarker(BaseUnmarker):
    def tag_some_tag(self, child) -> str:
        ...  # parse code here

To reduce code duplication, if your tag also has aliases (e.g. strong is an alias for b in HTML) then you may modify the TAG_ALIASES.

If you really need to, you may also modify DEFAULT_TAG_ALIASES. Be warned: if you do so, you will also need to implement the aliases (currently em and strong).

Utility functions when overriding

You may use (when extending) the following functions:

  • __parse, 2 parameters:
    • html: bs4.BeautifulSoup
      • The html to unmark. This is used internally by the unmark method and is slightly faster.
    • escape: bool
      • Whether to escape the characters inside the string or not. Defaults to False.
  • escape: 1 parameter:
    • string: str
      • The string to escape and make markdown-safe
  • wrap: 2 parameters:
    • element: bs4.BeautifulSoup
      • The element to wrap.
    • around_with: str
      • The character to wrap the element around with. WILL NOT BE ESCPAED
  • And, of course, tag_* and detect_language.

GitHub

https://github.com/ThatXliner/unmarkd